{ "meta": { "stage": "FINAL hold-out ground truth (upgrade-authority / upgrade-path task)", "provenance": "frozen frame -> sealed predictions (not opened) -> AI-blinded primary adjudication -> blinded human second review (37-case subset) -> reconciliation -> this final GT", "status": "AI-blinded primary adjudication + human second review of the 37-case stratified subset (all AGREE); primary retained for the 84 non-subset cases", "scope_limitation": "upgrade-path only; overall fastest fund-reaching fields are UNRESOLVED/UNKNOWN for all rows by design and are NOT ground truth", "n": 121, "second_review_coverage": 37, "human_reviewer": "duc", "reconciliation": { "AGREE": 37, "DISAGREE": 0, "UNCERTAIN": 0, "labels_changed": 0, "unresolved_disagreements": 0 }, "frozen_utc": "2026-09-10T06:58:15Z", "source_artifacts": { "primary_ai_blinded_sha256": "edd56d41f6726c6018fa1564bb54cd79236c79030aa72faa1199120907a81524", "scoring_protocol_sha256": "3c5338bdcb2ffa644f59db5fe9f94327235c4dfb5ccc1af1c157cda8d22c33ef", "R_B_adapter_sha256": "83f50141c5bd3f5bf381231aa4646063f1778125e28ba57297b277f4ea7f4fa9", "deployment_frame_sha256": "f7e4d2f3ba6a3de64729bfc28c813f2bce08d913defbf014598b383c2963ff01" } }, "ground_truth": [ { "protocol_slug": "liquity-v1", "protocol_name": "Liquity V1", "rank": 103, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x24179cd81c9e782a4096035f7ec97fb8b783e007", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/liquity-v1__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/liquity-v1__ethereum.json", "raw_state/liquity-v1__ethereum.json" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "axelar", "protocol_name": "Axelar", "rank": 104, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0xe432150cce91c13a887f7d836923d5597add8e31", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/axelar__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "custom Axelar gateway proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade(address,bytes)", "upgrade_guard": "onlyAdmin / threshold-vote authorization", "authorization_dependency": "threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)", "authority_contract_or_state": "Axelar gateway admin-threshold state", "terminal_actor": "effective Axelar admin set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "multi-admin threshold consent enforced by the upgrade guard; effective member set not publicly enumerable", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state + event history", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/axelar__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/axelar__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/axelar__arbitrum/AxelarGatewayProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__arbitrum__impl/@axelar-network__axelar-gmp-sdk-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IAxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__arbitrum__impl/contracts__AxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__arbitrum__impl/@axelar-network__axelar-gmp-sdk-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IContractIdentifier.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "notes": "The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "axelar", "protocol_name": "Axelar", "rank": 104, "chain": "base", "address": "0xe432150cce91c13a887f7d836923d5597add8e31", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/axelar__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "custom Axelar gateway proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade(address,bytes)", "upgrade_guard": "onlyAdmin / threshold-vote authorization", "authorization_dependency": "threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)", "authority_contract_or_state": "Axelar gateway admin-threshold state", "terminal_actor": "effective Axelar admin set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "multi-admin threshold consent enforced by the upgrade guard; effective member set not publicly enumerable", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state + event history", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/axelar__base.json", "raw_state/axelar__base.json", "workspace/sources/axelar__base/contracts__AxelarGatewayProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__base__impl/@axelar-network__axelar-gmp-sdk-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IAxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__base__impl/contracts__AxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__base/contracts__interfaces__IAxelarGateway.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "notes": "The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "axelar", "protocol_name": "Axelar", "rank": 104, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x304acf330bbe08d1e512eefaa92f6a57871fd895", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/axelar__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "custom Axelar gateway proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade(address,bytes)", "upgrade_guard": "onlyAdmin / threshold-vote authorization", "authorization_dependency": "threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)", "authority_contract_or_state": "Axelar gateway admin-threshold state", "terminal_actor": "effective Axelar admin set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "multi-admin threshold consent enforced by the upgrade guard; effective member set not publicly enumerable", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state + event history", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/axelar__bsc.json", "raw_state/axelar__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/axelar__bsc/AxelarGatewayProxy.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "notes": "The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "axelar", "protocol_name": "Axelar", "rank": 104, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x4f4495243837681061c4743b74b3eedf548d56a5", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/axelar__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "custom Axelar gateway proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade(address,bytes)", "upgrade_guard": "onlyAdmin / threshold-vote authorization", "authorization_dependency": "threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)", "authority_contract_or_state": "Axelar gateway admin-threshold state", "terminal_actor": "effective Axelar admin set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "multi-admin threshold consent enforced by the upgrade guard; effective member set not publicly enumerable", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state + event history", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/axelar__ethereum.json", "raw_state/axelar__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/axelar__ethereum/AxelarGatewayProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__ethereum/AxelarGatewayProxyMultisig.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__ethereum__impl/@axelar-network__axelar-gmp-sdk-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IAxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__ethereum__impl/contracts__AxelarGateway.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "notes": "The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "axelar", "protocol_name": "Axelar", "rank": 104, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0xe432150cce91c13a887f7d836923d5597add8e31", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/axelar__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "custom Axelar gateway proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade(address,bytes)", "upgrade_guard": "onlyAdmin / threshold-vote authorization", "authorization_dependency": "threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)", "authority_contract_or_state": "Axelar gateway admin-threshold state", "terminal_actor": "effective Axelar admin set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "multi-admin threshold consent enforced by the upgrade guard; effective member set not publicly enumerable", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state + event history", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/axelar__optimism.json", "raw_state/axelar__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/axelar__optimism/contracts__AxelarGatewayProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__optimism__impl/@axelar-network__axelar-gmp-sdk-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IAxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__optimism__impl/contracts__AxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__optimism/contracts__interfaces__IAxelarGateway.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "notes": "The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "axelar", "protocol_name": "Axelar", "rank": 104, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0x6f015f16de9fc8791b234ef68d486d2bf203fba8", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/axelar__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "custom Axelar gateway proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade(address,bytes)", "upgrade_guard": "onlyAdmin / threshold-vote authorization", "authorization_dependency": "threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)", "authority_contract_or_state": "Axelar gateway admin-threshold state", "terminal_actor": "effective Axelar admin set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "multi-admin threshold consent enforced by the upgrade guard; effective member set not publicly enumerable", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state + event history", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/axelar__polygon.json", "raw_state/axelar__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/axelar__polygon/AxelarGatewayProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__polygon/AxelarGatewayProxyMultisig.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__polygon/AxelarGateway.sol", "workspace/sources/axelar__polygon/AxelarGatewayMultisig.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (threshold-admin authorization state (admin epoch / threshold / vote state)) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "notes": "The mechanism and threshold authorization are identifiable, but the effective admin membership cannot be established from the neutral public evidence; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than T3.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "aerodrome-v1", "protocol_name": "Aerodrome V1", "rank": 105, "chain": "base", "address": "0x420dd381b31aef6683db6b902084cb0ffece40da", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/aerodrome-v1__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/aerodrome-v1__base.json", "raw_state/aerodrome-v1__base.json" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "yield-basis", "protocol_name": "Yield Basis", "rank": 106, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x370a449febb9411c95bf897021377fe0b7d100c0", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/yield-basis__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/yield-basis__ethereum.json", "raw_state/yield-basis__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/yield-basis__ethereum/contracts__Factory.vy" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "bedrock-unibtc", "protocol_name": "Bedrock uniBTC", "rank": 107, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0x84e5c854a7ff9f49c888d69deca578d406c26800", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin controlled by Safe", "terminal_actor": "0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/bedrock-unibtc__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__arbitrum/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__arbitrum__impl/VaultWithoutNative.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "bedrock-unibtc", "protocol_name": "Bedrock uniBTC", "rank": 107, "chain": "base", "address": "0x9f283b0401d9698e86097fdc44820bcbe5dcfefb", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin controlled by Safe", "terminal_actor": "0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__base.json", "raw_state/bedrock-unibtc__base.json", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__base/lib__OpenZeppelin__openzeppelin-contracts@4.8.3__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__base__impl/lib__OpenZeppelin__openzeppelin-contracts@4.8.3__contracts__token__ERC20__ERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__base__impl/lib__OpenZeppelin__openzeppelin-contracts@4.8.3__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__base__impl/lib__OpenZeppelin__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable@4.8.3__contracts__access__AccessControlUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "bedrock-unibtc", "protocol_name": "Bedrock uniBTC", "rank": 107, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x84e5c854a7ff9f49c888d69deca578d406c26800", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin controlled by Safe", "terminal_actor": "0x1Ae02CD8a4566A4f2432857D7A943765D1e3E757", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__bsc.json", "raw_state/bedrock-unibtc__bsc.json" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x1Ae02CD8a4566A4f2432857D7A943765D1e3E757, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "bedrock-unibtc", "protocol_name": "Bedrock uniBTC", "rank": 107, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x047d41f2544b7f63a8e991af2068a363d210d6da", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin controlled by Safe", "terminal_actor": "0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__ethereum.json", "raw_state/bedrock-unibtc__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__ethereum/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__ethereum__impl/lib__OpenZeppelin__openzeppelin-contracts@4.8.3__contracts__token__ERC20__ERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__ethereum__impl/lib__OpenZeppelin__openzeppelin-contracts@4.8.3__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__ethereum__impl/lib__OpenZeppelin__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable@4.8.3__contracts__access__AccessControlUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "bedrock-unibtc", "protocol_name": "Bedrock uniBTC", "rank": 107, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0xf9775085d726e782e83585033b58606f7731ab18", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin controlled by Safe", "terminal_actor": "0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/bedrock-unibtc__optimism.json", "raw_state/bedrock-unibtc__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__optimism/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__optimism__impl/VaultWithoutNative.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__optimism/ERC1967Proxy.sol", "workspace/sources/bedrock-unibtc__optimism/Proxy.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zksync-era-txbridge", "protocol_name": "zkSync Era txBridge", "rank": 111, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xbed1eb542f9a5aa6419ff3deb921a372681111f6", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/zksync-era-txbridge__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() chain", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin -> intermediate upgradeable owner contract", "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": "unresolved", "upgrade_delay": null, "governance_requirement": "unknown", "upgrade_path_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "UNRESOLVED", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zksync-era-txbridge__ethereum.json", "raw_state/zksync-era-txbridge__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/zksync-era-txbridge__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-v4__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/zksync-era-txbridge__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-v4__contracts__proxy__beacon__BeaconProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/zksync-era-txbridge__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-v4__contracts__proxy__beacon__IBeacon.sol", "workspace/sources/zksync-era-txbridge__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-v4__contracts__utils__Create2.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism is identifiable as transparent EIP-1967 proxy, but the authorization path cannot be walked to a sufficiently established terminal controller from the blinded evidence; the upgrade-path outcome is UNRESOLVED. The admin/owner dependency is visible, but the terminal controller of the intermediate upgradeable owner was not established from the blinded evidence depth.", "notes": "The admin/owner dependency is visible, but the terminal controller of the intermediate upgradeable owner was not established from the blinded evidence depth.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "aster-usdf", "protocol_name": "Aster USDF", "rank": 115, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x5a110fc00474038f6c02e89c707d638602ea44b5", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/aster-usdf__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/aster-usdf__bsc.json", "raw_state/aster-usdf__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/aster-usdf__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-protocol-v2__contracts__interfaces__ILayerZeroEndpointV2.sol", "workspace/sources/aster-usdf__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-protocol-v2__contracts__interfaces__ILayerZeroReceiver.sol", "workspace/sources/aster-usdf__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-protocol-v2__contracts__interfaces__IMessageLib.sol", "workspace/sources/aster-usdf__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-protocol-v2__contracts__interfaces__IMessageLibManager.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "midas-rwa", "protocol_name": "Midas RWA", "rank": 117, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0xdd629e5241cbc5919847783e6c96b2de4754e438", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/midas-rwa__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0x875c06A295C41c27840b9C9dfDA7f3d819d8bC6A", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/midas-rwa__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/midas-rwa__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__arbitrum/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__ProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__arbitrum/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__arbitrum__impl/contracts__mTBILL__mTBILL.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__arbitrum__impl/contracts__access__Blacklistable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0x875c06A295C41c27840b9C9dfDA7f3d819d8bC6A, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "midas-rwa", "protocol_name": "Midas RWA", "rank": 117, "chain": "base", "address": "0xdd629e5241cbc5919847783e6c96b2de4754e438", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/midas-rwa__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership via timelock", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "MidasTimelock", "terminal_actor": "0x9230F9cBAca32bad2B19CAB331d3e6509B8EB0cB", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 172800, "governance_requirement": "enforced 172800-second timelock before upgrade execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/midas-rwa__base.json", "raw_state/midas-rwa__base.json", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__base/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__ProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__base__impl/contracts__mTBILL__mTBILL.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__base__impl/contracts__interfaces__IMTbill.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__base__impl/contracts__access__Blacklistable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() and must traverse an enforced delay of 172800 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "midas-rwa", "protocol_name": "Midas RWA", "rank": 117, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xdd629e5241cbc5919847783e6c96b2de4754e438", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/midas-rwa__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership via timelock", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "MidasTimelock", "terminal_actor": "0xE3EEe3e0D2398799C884a47FC40C029C8e241852", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 172800, "governance_requirement": "enforced 172800-second timelock before upgrade execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/midas-rwa__ethereum.json", "raw_state/midas-rwa__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__ProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__ethereum__impl/contracts__mTBILL.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__ethereum__impl/contracts__interfaces__IMTbill.sol", "workspace/sources/midas-rwa__ethereum__impl/contracts__access__Blacklistable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() and must traverse an enforced delay of 172800 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "frax-usd", "protocol_name": "Frax USD", "rank": 118, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xcacd6fd266af91b8aed52accc382b4e165586e29", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/frax-usd__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership via timelock", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "timelock-controlled ProxyAdmin", "terminal_actor": "0xb898Ad2976b4d8f2E21521C9db16b7497825E503", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 86400, "governance_requirement": "enforced 86400-second timelock; admin control includes a Safe", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/frax-usd__ethereum.json", "raw_state/frax-usd__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/frax-usd__ethereum/node_modules__@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/frax-usd__ethereum/node_modules__@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__ProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/frax-usd__ethereum__impl/src__contracts__ethereum__frxUSD__FrxUSD.sol", "workspace/sources/frax-usd__ethereum__impl/src__contracts__ethereum__frxUSD__versioning__FrxUSD3.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() and must traverse an enforced delay of 86400 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "uncx-network-v2", "protocol_name": "UNCX Network V2", "rank": 120, "chain": "base", "address": "0xc4e637d37113192f4f1f060daebd7758de7f4131", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/uncx-network-v2__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/uncx-network-v2__base.json", "raw_state/uncx-network-v2__base.json", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__base/contracts__ICountryList.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__base/contracts__TransferHelper.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__base/contracts__UniswapV2Locker.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__base/@openzeppelin__contracts__access__Ownable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "uncx-network-v2", "protocol_name": "UNCX Network V2", "rank": 120, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0xc765bddb93b0d1c1a88282ba0fa6b2d00e3e0c83", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/uncx-network-v2__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/uncx-network-v2__bsc.json", "raw_state/uncx-network-v2__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__bsc/Context.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__bsc/EnumerableSet.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__bsc/Ownable.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__bsc/ReentrancyGuard.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "uncx-network-v2", "protocol_name": "UNCX Network V2", "rank": 120, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x663a5c229c09b049e36dcc11a9b0d4a8eb9db214", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/uncx-network-v2__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/uncx-network-v2__ethereum.json", "raw_state/uncx-network-v2__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__ethereum/Context.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__ethereum/EnumerableSet.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__ethereum/Ownable.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__ethereum/ReentrancyGuard.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "uncx-network-v2", "protocol_name": "UNCX Network V2", "rank": 120, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0x5923c3911d9424f7725cad33ed176a6b885484d6", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/uncx-network-v2__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/uncx-network-v2__optimism.json", "raw_state/uncx-network-v2__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__optimism/contracts__ICountryList.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__optimism/contracts__TransferHelper.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__optimism/contracts__UniswapV2Locker.sol", "workspace/sources/uncx-network-v2__optimism/@openzeppelin__contracts__access__Ownable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "aave-v2", "protocol_name": "Aave V2", "rank": 122, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x7d2768de32b0b80b7a3454c06bdac94a69ddc7a9", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/aave-v2__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "Aave immutable-admin upgradeability proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade implementation through immutable-admin proxy/provider path", "upgrade_guard": "immutable ADMIN / provider governance control", "authorization_dependency": "immutable ADMIN -> LendingPoolAddressesProvider -> governance executor", "authority_contract_or_state": "Aave governance execution chain", "terminal_actor": "0xdAbad81aF85554E9ae636395611C58F7eC1aAEc5", "terminal_actor_type": "governance system", "upgrade_delay": 86400, "governance_requirement": "governance vote/consent followed by executor; executor path has 86400-second delay", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/aave-v2__ethereum.json", "raw_state/aave-v2__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__ethereum__impl/src__contracts__interfaces__ILendingPoolAddressesProvider.sol", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__ethereum__impl/src__contracts__protocol__lendingpool__LendingPool.sol", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__ethereum__impl/src__contracts__interfaces__ILendingPool.sol", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__ethereum__impl/src__contracts__protocol__lendingpool__LendingPoolStorage.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is Aave immutable-admin upgradeability proxy; the path depends on immutable ADMIN -> LendingPoolAddressesProvider -> governance executor and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "aave-v2", "protocol_name": "Aave V2", "rank": 122, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0x8dff5e27ea6b7ac08ebfdf9eb090f32ee9a30fcf", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/aave-v2__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "Aave immutable-admin upgradeability proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgrade implementation through immutable-admin proxy/provider path", "upgrade_guard": "immutable ADMIN / provider governance control", "authorization_dependency": "immutable ADMIN -> LendingPoolAddressesProvider -> governance/bridge executor", "authority_contract_or_state": "Aave Polygon governance execution chain", "terminal_actor": "0x401B5D0294E23637c18fcc38b1Bca814CDa2637C", "terminal_actor_type": "governance/bridge executor", "upgrade_delay": 172800, "governance_requirement": "governance/bridge executor consent; 172800-second executor delay", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/aave-v2__polygon.json", "raw_state/aave-v2__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__polygon__impl/src__contracts__v2PolPool__LendingPool__contracts__interfaces__ILendingPoolAddressesProvider.sol", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__polygon/contracts__interfaces__ILendingPoolAddressesProvider.sol", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__polygon/contracts__protocol__configuration__LendingPoolAddressesProviderRegistry.sol", "workspace/sources/aave-v2__polygon/contracts__interfaces__ILendingPoolAddressesProviderRegistry.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is Aave immutable-admin upgradeability proxy; the path depends on immutable ADMIN -> LendingPoolAddressesProvider -> governance/bridge executor and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "raac", "protocol_name": "RAAC", "rank": 123, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x7a7f847fb60b0000e24cce07298dc73df8b8e56a", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/raac__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin.upgrade / upgradeAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0xCa3144AAD1f75557E68B16C8C7e893112418f13C", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 2", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/raac__ethereum.json", "raw_state/raac__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/raac__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__ProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/raac__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/raac__ethereum__impl/contracts__rwaf__TokenBlender.sol", "workspace/sources/raac__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__access__IAccessControl.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xCa3144AAD1f75557E68B16C8C7e893112418f13C, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "aster-asbnb", "protocol_name": "Aster asBNB", "rank": 124, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x77734e70b6e88b4d82fe632a168edf6e700912b6", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/aster-asbnb__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/aster-asbnb__bsc.json", "raw_state/aster-asbnb__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/aster-asbnb__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__ERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/aster-asbnb__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__Ownable2Step.sol", "workspace/sources/aster-asbnb__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__extensions__ERC20Permit.sol", "workspace/sources/aster-asbnb__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund", "protocol_name": "Securitize Tokenized AAA CLO Fund", "rank": 125, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x51c2d74017390cbbd30550179a16a1c28f7210fc", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade", "upgrade_guard": "onlyMaster (owner OR trust-service ROLE_MASTER)", "authorization_dependency": "onlyMaster authorization with owner OR master-role branch", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner()/ROLE_MASTER authorization", "terminal_actor": "0x59c1eAcEc450c57Dcb9b8725d0F96635C2b676Ee", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none; owner branch is independently sufficient and immediate", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund__ethereum.json", "raw_state/securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund__ethereum__impl/contracts__utils__BaseDSContract.sol", "workspace/sources/securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund__ethereum__impl/contracts__compliance__IDSComplianceConfigurationService.sol", "workspace/sources/securitize-tokenized-aaa-clo-fund__ethereum__impl/contracts__compliance__IDSComplianceService.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on onlyMaster authorization with owner OR master-role branch. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0x59c1eAcEc450c57Dcb9b8725d0F96635C2b676Ee, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "frax-ether", "protocol_name": "Frax Ether", "rank": 128, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x5e8422345238f34275888049021821e8e08caa1f", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/frax-ether__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/frax-ether__ethereum.json", "raw_state/frax-ether__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/frax-ether__ethereum/frxETH.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "hyperlane", "protocol_name": "Hyperlane", "rank": 129, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0x979ca5202784112f4738403dbec5d0f3b9daabb9", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/hyperlane__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership via timelock", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "timelock owner", "terminal_actor": "0xAC98b0cD1B64EA4fe133C6D2EDaf842cE5cF4b01", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 604800, "governance_requirement": "enforced 604800-second timelock; proposer control includes Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/hyperlane__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/hyperlane__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__arbitrum__impl/Mailbox.sol", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__arbitrum/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() and must traverse an enforced delay of 604800 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "hyperlane", "protocol_name": "Hyperlane", "rank": 129, "chain": "base", "address": "0xea87ae93fa0019a82a727bfd3ebd1cfca8f64f1d", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/hyperlane__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0x890ac177Fe3052B8676A65f32C1589Bc329f3d50", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 6", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/hyperlane__base.json", "raw_state/hyperlane__base.json", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__base/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__base__impl/Mailbox.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x890ac177Fe3052B8676A65f32C1589Bc329f3d50, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "hyperlane", "protocol_name": "Hyperlane", "rank": 129, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x2971b9aec44be4eb673df1b88cdb57b96eefe8a4", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/hyperlane__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0x7379D7bB2ccA68982E467632B6554fD4e72e9431", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 6", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/hyperlane__bsc.json", "raw_state/hyperlane__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__bsc/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__bsc__impl/Mailbox.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x7379D7bB2ccA68982E467632B6554fD4e72e9431, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "hyperlane", "protocol_name": "Hyperlane", "rank": 129, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xc005dc82818d67af737725bd4bf75435d065d239", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/hyperlane__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0x562Dfaac27A84be6C96273F5c9594DA1681C0DA7", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 6", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/hyperlane__ethereum.json", "raw_state/hyperlane__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__ethereum/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__ethereum__impl/Mailbox.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x562Dfaac27A84be6C96273F5c9594DA1681C0DA7, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "hyperlane", "protocol_name": "Hyperlane", "rank": 129, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0xd4c1905bb1d26bc93dac913e13cacc278cdcc80d", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/hyperlane__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0x890ac177Fe3052B8676A65f32C1589Bc329f3d50", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 6", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/hyperlane__optimism.json", "raw_state/hyperlane__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__optimism/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__optimism__impl/Mailbox.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x890ac177Fe3052B8676A65f32C1589Bc329f3d50, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "hyperlane", "protocol_name": "Hyperlane", "rank": 129, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0x5d934f4e2f797775e53561bb72aca21ba36b96bb", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/hyperlane__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "interchain ownership chain", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin -> OwnableMulticall -> InterchainAccountRouter", "authority_contract_or_state": "remote/interchain administrative control chain", "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": "unresolved", "upgrade_delay": null, "governance_requirement": "unknown", "upgrade_path_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "UNRESOLVED", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/hyperlane__polygon.json", "raw_state/hyperlane__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__polygon__impl/Mailbox.sol", "workspace/sources/hyperlane__polygon/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism is identifiable as transparent EIP-1967 proxy, but the authorization path cannot be walked to a sufficiently established terminal controller from the blinded evidence; the upgrade-path outcome is UNRESOLVED. The neutral evidence forms a control loop through OwnableMulticall/InterchainAccountRouter; the remote terminal controller was not established.", "notes": "The neutral evidence forms a control loop through OwnableMulticall/InterchainAccountRouter; the remote terminal controller was not established.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "usual-usd0", "protocol_name": "Usual USD0", "rank": 131, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x73a15fed60bf67631dc6cd7bc5b6e8da8190acf5", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/usual-usd0__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0xaaDa24358620d4638a2eE8788244c6F4b197Ca16", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 8", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/usual-usd0__ethereum.json", "raw_state/usual-usd0__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/usual-usd0__ethereum/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/usual-usd0__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/usual-usd0__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__token__ERC20__ERC20Upgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/usual-usd0__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__ERC20.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xaaDa24358620d4638a2eE8788244c6F4b197Ca16, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "compound-v2", "protocol_name": "Compound V2", "rank": 133, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x3d9819210a31b4961b30ef54be2aed79b9c9cd3b", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/compound-v2__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "Unitroller / Comptroller delegator", "upgrade_sink": "Unitroller implementation/admin upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "admin = Compound Timelock", "authorization_dependency": "Unitroller admin", "authority_contract_or_state": "Timelock -> GovernorBravo governance chain", "terminal_actor": "0x309a862bbC1A00e45506cB8A802D1ff10004c8C0", "terminal_actor_type": "governor", "upgrade_delay": 172800, "governance_requirement": "GovernorBravo proposal/vote required before timelock execution; timelock delay 172800 seconds", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/compound-v2__ethereum.json", "raw_state/compound-v2__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/compound-v2__ethereum__impl/contracts__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/compound-v2__ethereum/Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/compound-v2__ethereum__impl/contracts__CToken.sol", "workspace/sources/compound-v2__ethereum__impl/contracts__CTokenInterfaces.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is Unitroller / Comptroller delegator; the path depends on Unitroller admin and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "renzo", "protocol_name": "Renzo", "rank": 134, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0x2416092f143378750bb29b79ed961ab195cceea5", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/renzo__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain", "authority_contract_or_state": "Safe-controlled upgrade admin", "terminal_actor": "0x0e60fd361fF5b90088e1782e6b21A7D177d462C5", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/renzo__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/renzo__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/renzo__arbitrum/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__arbitrum__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__contracts__XERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__arbitrum__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__interfaces__IXERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__arbitrum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__access__OwnableUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x0e60fd361fF5b90088e1782e6b21A7D177d462C5, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "renzo", "protocol_name": "Renzo", "rank": 134, "chain": "base", "address": "0x2416092f143378750bb29b79ed961ab195cceea5", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/renzo__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain", "authority_contract_or_state": "Safe-controlled upgrade admin", "terminal_actor": "0x8410927C286A38883BC23721e640F31D3E3E79F8", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/renzo__base.json", "raw_state/renzo__base.json", "workspace/sources/renzo__base/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__base__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__contracts__XERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__base__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__interfaces__IXERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__base__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__access__OwnableUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x8410927C286A38883BC23721e640F31D3E3E79F8, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "renzo", "protocol_name": "Renzo", "rank": 134, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x2416092f143378750bb29b79ed961ab195cceea5", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/renzo__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain", "authority_contract_or_state": "Safe-controlled upgrade admin", "terminal_actor": "0x0e60fd361fF5b90088e1782e6b21A7D177d462C5", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/renzo__bsc.json", "raw_state/renzo__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/renzo__bsc/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__bsc__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__contracts__XERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__bsc__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__interfaces__IXERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__bsc__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__access__OwnableUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x0e60fd361fF5b90088e1782e6b21A7D177d462C5, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "renzo", "protocol_name": "Renzo", "rank": 134, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xbf5495efe5db9ce00f80364c8b423567e58d2110", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/renzo__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership via TimelockController", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "TimelockController", "terminal_actor": "0x81F6e9914136Da1A1d3b1eFd14F7E0761c3d4cc7", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 604800, "governance_requirement": "enforced 604800-second timelock; proposer set includes direct account/Safe", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/renzo__ethereum.json", "raw_state/renzo__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/renzo__ethereum__impl/contracts__Errors__Errors.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__ethereum__impl/contracts__Permissions__IRoleManager.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__ethereum__impl/contracts__token__EzEthToken.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__ethereum__impl/contracts__token__EzEthTokenStorage.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() and must traverse an enforced delay of 604800 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "renzo", "protocol_name": "Renzo", "rank": 134, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0x2416092f143378750bb29b79ed961ab195cceea5", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/renzo__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain", "authority_contract_or_state": "Safe-controlled upgrade admin", "terminal_actor": "0x8410927C286A38883BC23721e640F31D3E3E79F8", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/renzo__optimism.json", "raw_state/renzo__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/renzo__optimism/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__optimism__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__contracts__XERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__optimism__impl/contracts__Bridge__xERC20__interfaces__IXERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/renzo__optimism__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__access__OwnableUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin/owner chain. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x8410927C286A38883BC23721e640F31D3E3E79F8, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "fx-protocol", "protocol_name": "fx Protocol", "rank": 136, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x250893ca4ba5d05626c785e8da758026928fcd24", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/fx-protocol__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership via TimelockController", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "TimelockController", "terminal_actor": "0x68863fb8855b04509a835082478D6E3D0bE4E61a", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 259200, "governance_requirement": "enforced 259200-second timelock; proposer is Safe threshold 6", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/fx-protocol__ethereum.json", "raw_state/fx-protocol__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/fx-protocol__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts-v4__proxy__transparent__ProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/fx-protocol__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts-v4__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/fx-protocol__ethereum/contracts__common__EIP2535__Diamond.sol", "workspace/sources/fx-protocol__ethereum/contracts__common__EIP2535__facets__DiamondCutFacet.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() and must traverse an enforced delay of 259200 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "usdd", "protocol_name": "USDD", "rank": 137, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0xd17479997f34dd9156deef8f95a52d81d265be9c", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/usdd__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/usdd__bsc.json", "raw_state/usdd__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/usdd__bsc/contracts__common__EIP712Base.sol", "workspace/sources/usdd__bsc/contracts__common__AccessControlMixin.sol", "workspace/sources/usdd__bsc/contracts__common__ContextMixin.sol", "workspace/sources/usdd__bsc/contracts__root__RootToken__USDD.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "usdd", "protocol_name": "USDD", "rank": 137, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x4f8e5de400de08b164e7421b3ee387f461becd1a", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/usdd__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/usdd__ethereum.json", "raw_state/usdd__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/usdd__ethereum/src__dss__usdd.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "sky-rwa", "protocol_name": "Sky RWA", "rank": 138, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x35d1b3f3d7966a1dfe207aa4514c12a259a0492b", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/sky-rwa__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/sky-rwa__ethereum.json", "raw_state/sky-rwa__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/sky-rwa__ethereum/Vat.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "nexus-mutual", "protocol_name": "Nexus Mutual", "rank": 140, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x01bfd82675dbcc7762c84019ca518e701c0cd07e", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/nexus-mutual__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "custom OwnedUpgradeabilityProxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgradeTo", "upgrade_guard": "onlyProxyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "custom proxy-owner storage slot", "authority_contract_or_state": "unknown current proxy owner", "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": "unresolved", "upgrade_delay": null, "governance_requirement": "unknown", "upgrade_path_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "UNRESOLVED", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/nexus-mutual__ethereum.json", "raw_state/nexus-mutual__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/nexus-mutual__ethereum/OwnedUpgradeabilityProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/nexus-mutual__ethereum__impl/contracts__abstract__RegistryAware.sol", "workspace/sources/nexus-mutual__ethereum__impl/contracts__interfaces__ILegacyMCR.sol", "workspace/sources/nexus-mutual__ethereum__impl/contracts__interfaces__ILegacyPool.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism is identifiable as custom OwnedUpgradeabilityProxy, but the authorization path cannot be walked to a sufficiently established terminal controller from the blinded evidence; the upgrade-path outcome is UNRESOLVED. Verified source defines a custom proxy-owner slot, but the neutral state bundle did not include that custom slot and no sufficient ownership-transfer history establishes its pinned-block value.", "notes": "Verified source defines a custom proxy-owner slot, but the neutral state bundle did not include that custom slot and no sufficient ownership-transfer history establishes its pinned-block value.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "avalon-cedefi", "protocol_name": "Avalon CeDeFi", "rank": 142, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x02fedcff97942fe28e8936cdc3d7a480fdd248f0", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/avalon-cedefi__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0xdFB1b1c0E0f697829aF500D73364D863Cb3c6cE9", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 5", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/avalon-cedefi__ethereum.json", "raw_state/avalon-cedefi__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/avalon-cedefi__ethereum/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/avalon-cedefi__ethereum__impl/PoolManager.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xdFB1b1c0E0f697829aF500D73364D863Cb3c6cE9, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "enzyme-finance", "protocol_name": "Enzyme Finance", "rank": 143, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0x8da28441a4c594fd2fac72726c1412d8cf9e4a19", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/enzyme-finance__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/enzyme-finance__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/enzyme-finance__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__arbitrum/contracts__persistent__dispatcher__Dispatcher.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__arbitrum/contracts__persistent__vault__interfaces__IMigratableVault.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__arbitrum/contracts__persistent__vault__VaultProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__arbitrum/contracts__persistent__dispatcher__IDispatcher.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The Dispatcher has migration/delegatecall mechanics for funds/modules but no self implementation-replacement path for the measured live deployment; treated as non-upgradeable for the upgrade-path target.", "notes": "The Dispatcher has migration/delegatecall mechanics for funds/modules but no self implementation-replacement path for the measured live deployment; treated as non-upgradeable for the upgrade-path target.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "enzyme-finance", "protocol_name": "Enzyme Finance", "rank": 143, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xc3dc853dd716bd5754f421ef94fdcbac3902ab32", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/enzyme-finance__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/enzyme-finance__ethereum.json", "raw_state/enzyme-finance__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__ethereum/contracts__persistent__dispatcher__Dispatcher.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__ethereum/contracts__persistent__dispatcher__IDispatcher.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__ethereum/contracts__persistent__utils__IMigratableVault.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__ethereum/contracts__persistent__utils__IMigrationHookHandler.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The Dispatcher has migration/delegatecall mechanics for funds/modules but no self implementation-replacement path for the measured live deployment; treated as non-upgradeable for the upgrade-path target.", "notes": "The Dispatcher has migration/delegatecall mechanics for funds/modules but no self implementation-replacement path for the measured live deployment; treated as non-upgradeable for the upgrade-path target.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "enzyme-finance", "protocol_name": "Enzyme Finance", "rank": 143, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0x2e25271297537b8124b8f883a92ffd95c4032733", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/enzyme-finance__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/enzyme-finance__polygon.json", "raw_state/enzyme-finance__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__polygon/contracts__persistent__dispatcher__Dispatcher.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__polygon/contracts__persistent__dispatcher__IDispatcher.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__polygon/contracts__persistent__dispatcher__IMigrationHookHandler.sol", "workspace/sources/enzyme-finance__polygon/contracts__persistent__vault__VaultProxy.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The Dispatcher has migration/delegatecall mechanics for funds/modules but no self implementation-replacement path for the measured live deployment; treated as non-upgradeable for the upgrade-path target.", "notes": "The Dispatcher has migration/delegatecall mechanics for funds/modules but no self implementation-replacement path for the measured live deployment; treated as non-upgradeable for the upgrade-path target.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "railgun", "protocol_name": "Railgun", "rank": 144, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0xfa7093cdd9ee6932b4eb2c9e1cde7ce00b1fa4b9", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/railgun__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain", "upgrade_sink": "proxy upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "governance-controlled admin/delegator", "authorization_dependency": "proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting", "authority_contract_or_state": "Railgun governance voting/execution system", "terminal_actor": "0xc480F68A3dcC3EdD82134FAB45C14A0FcF1dA3CC", "terminal_actor_type": "governance voting/executor", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "protocol governance vote/consent required before upgrade execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/railgun__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/railgun__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/railgun__arbitrum__impl/contracts__logic__Commitments.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__arbitrum__impl/contracts__logic__Globals.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__arbitrum__impl/contracts__logic__Poseidon.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__arbitrum__impl/contracts__logic__RailgunLogic.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain; the path depends on proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3. Arbitrum is medium confidence because the terminal is an executor/relay and the full remote governance path is less directly evidenced.", "notes": "Arbitrum is medium confidence because the terminal is an executor/relay and the full remote governance path is less directly evidenced.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "railgun", "protocol_name": "Railgun", "rank": 144, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x590162bf4b50f6576a459b75309ee21d92178a10", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/railgun__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain", "upgrade_sink": "proxy upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "governance-controlled admin/delegator", "authorization_dependency": "proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting", "authority_contract_or_state": "Railgun governance voting/execution system", "terminal_actor": "0xc3f2C8F9d5F0705De706b1302B7a039e1e11aC88", "terminal_actor_type": "governance voting/executor", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "protocol governance vote/consent required before upgrade execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/railgun__bsc.json", "raw_state/railgun__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/railgun__bsc__impl/contracts__logic__Commitments.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__bsc__impl/contracts__logic__Globals.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__bsc__impl/contracts__logic__Poseidon.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__bsc__impl/contracts__logic__RailgunLogic.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain; the path depends on proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "railgun", "protocol_name": "Railgun", "rank": 144, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xfa7093cdd9ee6932b4eb2c9e1cde7ce00b1fa4b9", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/railgun__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain", "upgrade_sink": "proxy upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "governance-controlled admin/delegator", "authorization_dependency": "proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting", "authority_contract_or_state": "Railgun governance voting/execution system", "terminal_actor": "0xc480F68A3dcC3EdD82134FAB45C14A0FcF1dA3CC", "terminal_actor_type": "governance voting/executor", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "protocol governance vote/consent required before upgrade execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/railgun__ethereum.json", "raw_state/railgun__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/railgun__ethereum__impl/contracts__logic__Commitments.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__ethereum__impl/contracts__logic__Globals.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__ethereum__impl/contracts__logic__Poseidon.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__ethereum__impl/contracts__logic__RailgunLogic.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain; the path depends on proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "railgun", "protocol_name": "Railgun", "rank": 144, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0x19b620929f97b7b990801496c3b361ca5def8c71", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/railgun__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain", "upgrade_sink": "proxy upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "governance-controlled admin/delegator", "authorization_dependency": "proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting", "authority_contract_or_state": "Railgun governance voting/execution system", "terminal_actor": "0xc3f2C8F9d5F0705De706b1302B7a039e1e11aC88", "terminal_actor_type": "governance voting/executor", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "protocol governance vote/consent required before upgrade execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/railgun__polygon.json", "raw_state/railgun__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/railgun__polygon__impl/contracts__logic__Commitments.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__polygon__impl/contracts__logic__Globals.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__polygon__impl/contracts__logic__Poseidon.sol", "workspace/sources/railgun__polygon__impl/contracts__logic__RailgunLogic.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent/custom proxy upgrade chain; the path depends on proxy admin/owner -> governance executor/delegator/voting and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "aera-v3", "protocol_name": "Aera V3", "rank": 145, "chain": "base", "address": "0x29722cc9a1cacff4a15914f9bc274b46f3b90b4f", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/aera-v3__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/aera-v3__base.json", "raw_state/aera-v3__base.json", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Address.sol", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__ShortStrings.sol", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__TransientSlot.sol", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Errors.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "aera-v3", "protocol_name": "Aera V3", "rank": 145, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x29722cc9a1cacff4a15914f9bc274b46f3b90b4f", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/aera-v3__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/aera-v3__ethereum.json", "raw_state/aera-v3__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Address.sol", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__ShortStrings.sol", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__TransientSlot.sol", "workspace/sources/aera-v3__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Errors.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "liquity-v2", "protocol_name": "Liquity V2", "rank": 149, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xf949982b91c8c61e952b3ba942cbbfaef5386684", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/liquity-v2__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/liquity-v2__ethereum.json", "raw_state/liquity-v2__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/liquity-v2__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__extensions__IERC20Metadata.sol", "workspace/sources/liquity-v2__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/liquity-v2__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__extensions__IERC20Permit.sol", "workspace/sources/liquity-v2__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__interfaces__IERC5267.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "apx-bridge", "protocol_name": "APX Bridge", "rank": 151, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0xb3879e95a4b8e3ee570c232b19d520821f540e48", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/apx-bridge__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "EIP-2535 diamond", "upgrade_sink": "diamondCut", "upgrade_guard": "AccessControl/admin role on diamond cut facet", "authorization_dependency": "diamondCut facet role/access-control authorization", "authority_contract_or_state": "diamond upgrade admin role", "terminal_actor": "0x60EdE4402a34762D608AD9bA7bD3797f5bFE544c", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; relevant admin Safe threshold 4", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/apx-bridge__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/apx-bridge__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__arbitrum__impl/contracts__diamond__libraries__LibAccessControlEnumerable.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__arbitrum/__contracts__diamond__ApolloX.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__arbitrum/__contracts__diamond__libraries__LibAccessControlEnumerable.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__arbitrum__impl/contracts__diamond__facets__PriceFacadeFacet.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is EIP-2535 diamond; the upgrade path depends on diamondCut facet role/access-control authorization. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x60EdE4402a34762D608AD9bA7bD3797f5bFE544c, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1. Role membership and immediate Safe control are evidenced; the exact current diamondCut facet source is not fully present in the neutral bundle, hence medium confidence.", "notes": "Role membership and immediate Safe control are evidenced; the exact current diamondCut facet source is not fully present in the neutral bundle, hence medium confidence.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "apx-bridge", "protocol_name": "APX Bridge", "rank": 151, "chain": "base", "address": "0x9d93e5b2364070bc9837e91833f162430246dd57", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/apx-bridge__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "EIP-2535 diamond", "upgrade_sink": "diamondCut", "upgrade_guard": "AccessControl/admin role on diamond cut facet", "authorization_dependency": "diamondCut facet role/access-control authorization", "authority_contract_or_state": "diamond upgrade admin role", "terminal_actor": "0x51993a8ec36fa7bdc054d08cd2961f2a66f3e900", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; relevant admin Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/apx-bridge__base.json", "raw_state/apx-bridge__base.json", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__base__impl/__contracts__diamond__libraries__LibAccessControlEnumerable.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__base/__contracts__diamond__ApolloX.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__base/__contracts__diamond__libraries__LibAccessControlEnumerable.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__base__impl/__contracts__diamond__facets__PriceFacadeFacet.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is EIP-2535 diamond; the upgrade path depends on diamondCut facet role/access-control authorization. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x51993a8ec36fa7bdc054d08cd2961f2a66f3e900, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1. Role membership and immediate Safe control are evidenced; the exact current diamondCut facet source is not fully present in the neutral bundle, hence medium confidence.", "notes": "Role membership and immediate Safe control are evidenced; the exact current diamondCut facet source is not fully present in the neutral bundle, hence medium confidence.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "apx-bridge", "protocol_name": "APX Bridge", "rank": 151, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x1b6f2d3844c6ae7d56ceb3c3643b9060ba28feb0", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/apx-bridge__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "EIP-2535 diamond", "upgrade_sink": "diamondCut", "upgrade_guard": "AccessControl/admin role on diamond cut facet", "authorization_dependency": "diamondCut facet role/access-control authorization", "authority_contract_or_state": "diamond upgrade admin role", "terminal_actor": "0x60ede4402a34762d608ad9ba7bd3797f5bfe544c", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; relevant admin Safe threshold 4", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/apx-bridge__bsc.json", "raw_state/apx-bridge__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__bsc__impl/contracts__diamond__libraries__LibAccessControlEnumerable.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__bsc/__contracts__diamond__ApolloX.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__bsc/__contracts__diamond__libraries__LibAccessControlEnumerable.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__bsc__impl/contracts__diamond__facets__PredictUpDownFacet.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is EIP-2535 diamond; the upgrade path depends on diamondCut facet role/access-control authorization. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x60ede4402a34762d608ad9ba7bd3797f5bfe544c, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1. Role membership and immediate Safe control are evidenced; the exact current diamondCut facet source is not fully present in the neutral bundle, hence medium confidence.", "notes": "Role membership and immediate Safe control are evidenced; the exact current diamondCut facet source is not fully present in the neutral bundle, hence medium confidence.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "apx-bridge", "protocol_name": "APX Bridge", "rank": 151, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xb40eed68d7d6b3b6d6f4e93de6239b7c53efc786", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/apx-bridge__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/apx-bridge__ethereum.json", "raw_state/apx-bridge__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__ethereum/__Users__user__workspace__cloud-protocol-eth__contracts__ApolloxExchangeTreasury.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts__utils__cryptography__ECDSA.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts__utils__Strings.sol", "workspace/sources/apx-bridge__ethereum/@openzeppelin__contracts__utils__Context.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "pancakeswap-infinity", "protocol_name": "PancakeSwap Infinity", "rank": 153, "chain": "base", "address": "0x238a358808379702088667322f80ac48bad5e6c4", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/pancakeswap-infinity__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/pancakeswap-infinity__base.json", "raw_state/pancakeswap-infinity__base.json", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__Ownable2Step.sol", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__Ownable.sol", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Context.sol", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__base/src__Vault.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "pancakeswap-infinity", "protocol_name": "PancakeSwap Infinity", "rank": 153, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x238a358808379702088667322f80ac48bad5e6c4", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/pancakeswap-infinity__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/pancakeswap-infinity__bsc.json", "raw_state/pancakeswap-infinity__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__Ownable2Step.sol", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__Ownable.sol", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Context.sol", "workspace/sources/pancakeswap-infinity__bsc/src__Vault.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "polygon-zkevm-bridge", "protocol_name": "Polygon zkEVM Bridge", "rank": 154, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x2a3dd3eb832af982ec71669e178424b10dca2ede", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/polygon-zkevm-bridge__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership via timelock", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "PolygonZkEVMTimelock", "terminal_actor": "0xEf1462451C30Ea7aD8555386226059Fe837CA4EF", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 259200, "governance_requirement": "enforced 259200-second timelock; proposer Safe threshold 5", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/polygon-zkevm-bridge__ethereum.json", "raw_state/polygon-zkevm-bridge__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/polygon-zkevm-bridge__ethereum__impl/contracts__interfaces__IProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/polygon-zkevm-bridge__ethereum/TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/polygon-zkevm-bridge__ethereum__impl/contracts__AgglayerBridge.sol", "workspace/sources/polygon-zkevm-bridge__ethereum__impl/contracts__interfaces__IAgglayerBridge.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner() and must traverse an enforced delay of 259200 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "vault-bridge", "protocol_name": "Vault Bridge", "rank": 155, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x417d01b64ea30c4e163873f3a1f77b727c689e02", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/vault-bridge__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0x9d851f8b8751c5FbC09b9E74E6e68E9950949052", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 2", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/vault-bridge__ethereum.json", "raw_state/vault-bridge__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/vault-bridge__ethereum/dependencies__@openzeppelin-contracts-5.1.0__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/vault-bridge__ethereum/dependencies__@openzeppelin-contracts-5.1.0__proxy__transparent__ProxyAdmin.sol", "workspace/sources/vault-bridge__ethereum__impl/src__MigrationManager.sol", "workspace/sources/vault-bridge__ethereum__impl/src__etc__IBridgeMessageReceiver.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x9d851f8b8751c5FbC09b9E74E6e68E9950949052, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "stargate-v2", "protocol_name": "Stargate V2", "rank": 157, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0x19cfce47ed54a88614648dc3f19a5980097007dd", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/stargate-v2__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/stargate-v2__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/stargate-v2__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__arbitrum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OApp.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__arbitrum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppCore.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__arbitrum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppReceiver.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__arbitrum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppSender.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "stargate-v2", "protocol_name": "Stargate V2", "rank": 157, "chain": "base", "address": "0x5634c4a5fed09819e3c46d86a965dd9447d86e47", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/stargate-v2__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/stargate-v2__base.json", "raw_state/stargate-v2__base.json", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__base/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OApp.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__base/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppCore.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__base/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppReceiver.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__base/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppSender.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "stargate-v2", "protocol_name": "Stargate V2", "rank": 157, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x6e3d884c96d640526f273c61dfcf08915ebd7e2b", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/stargate-v2__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/stargate-v2__bsc.json", "raw_state/stargate-v2__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OApp.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppCore.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppReceiver.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__bsc/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppSender.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "stargate-v2", "protocol_name": "Stargate V2", "rank": 157, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x6d6620efa72948c5f68a3c8646d58c00d3f4a980", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/stargate-v2__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/stargate-v2__ethereum.json", "raw_state/stargate-v2__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__ethereum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OApp.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__ethereum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppCore.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__ethereum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppReceiver.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__ethereum/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppSender.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "stargate-v2", "protocol_name": "Stargate V2", "rank": 157, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0xf1fcb4cbd57b67d683972a59b6a7b1e2e8bf27e6", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/stargate-v2__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/stargate-v2__optimism.json", "raw_state/stargate-v2__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__optimism/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OApp.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__optimism/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppCore.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__optimism/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppReceiver.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__optimism/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppSender.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "stargate-v2", "protocol_name": "Stargate V2", "rank": 157, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0x6ce9bf8cdab780416ad1fd87b318a077d2f50eac", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/stargate-v2__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/stargate-v2__polygon.json", "raw_state/stargate-v2__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__polygon/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OApp.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__polygon/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppCore.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__polygon/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppReceiver.sol", "workspace/sources/stargate-v2__polygon/@layerzerolabs__lz-evm-oapp-v2__contracts__oapp__OAppSender.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "river-omni-cdp", "protocol_name": "River Omni-CDP", "rank": 160, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0x07bbc5a83b83a5c440d1caedbf1081426d0aa4ec", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/river-omni-cdp__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond", "upgrade_sink": "diamondCut", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "diamondCut onlyOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "diamond owner", "terminal_actor": "0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/river-omni-cdp__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/river-omni-cdp__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__arbitrum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IERC2535DiamondCut.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__arbitrum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__proxy__diamond__writable__DiamondWritable.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__arbitrum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IERC2535DiamondCutInternal.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__arbitrum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__proxy__diamond__writable__IDiamondWritable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond; the upgrade path depends on diamondCut onlyOwner. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "river-omni-cdp", "protocol_name": "River Omni-CDP", "rank": 160, "chain": "base", "address": "0x9a3c724ee9603a7550499be73dc743b371811dd3", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/river-omni-cdp__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond", "upgrade_sink": "diamondCut", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "diamondCut onlyOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "diamond owner", "terminal_actor": "0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/river-omni-cdp__base.json", "raw_state/river-omni-cdp__base.json", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__base/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IERC2535DiamondCut.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__base/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__proxy__diamond__writable__DiamondWritable.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__base/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IERC2535DiamondCutInternal.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__base/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__proxy__diamond__writable__IDiamondWritable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond; the upgrade path depends on diamondCut onlyOwner. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "river-omni-cdp", "protocol_name": "River Omni-CDP", "rank": 160, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x07bbc5a83b83a5c440d1caedbf1081426d0aa4ec", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/river-omni-cdp__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond", "upgrade_sink": "diamondCut", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "diamondCut onlyOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "diamond owner", "terminal_actor": "0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/river-omni-cdp__bsc.json", "raw_state/river-omni-cdp__bsc.json" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond; the upgrade path depends on diamondCut onlyOwner. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1. BSC verified application source was absent, but the live runtime bytecode is byte-for-byte identical to the Base deployment whose diamondCut onlyOwner path is verified, and the same owner is read at the pinned block.", "notes": "BSC verified application source was absent, but the live runtime bytecode is byte-for-byte identical to the Base deployment whose diamondCut onlyOwner path is verified, and the same owner is read at the pinned block.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "river-omni-cdp", "protocol_name": "River Omni-CDP", "rank": 160, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x07bbc5a83b83a5c440d1caedbf1081426d0aa4ec", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/river-omni-cdp__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond", "upgrade_sink": "diamondCut", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "diamondCut onlyOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "diamond owner", "terminal_actor": "0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/river-omni-cdp__ethereum.json", "raw_state/river-omni-cdp__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__ethereum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IERC2535DiamondCut.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__ethereum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__proxy__diamond__writable__DiamondWritable.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__ethereum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__interfaces__IERC2535DiamondCutInternal.sol", "workspace/sources/river-omni-cdp__ethereum/lib__solidstate-solidity__contracts__proxy__diamond__writable__IDiamondWritable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is SolidState/EIP-2535 diamond; the upgrade path depends on diamondCut onlyOwner. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0xd3e87B4B76E6F8bFf454AAFc2AD3271C5b317d47, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "frankencoin", "protocol_name": "Frankencoin", "rank": 161, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xb58e61c3098d85632df34eecfb899a1ed80921cb", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/frankencoin__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/frankencoin__ethereum.json", "raw_state/frankencoin__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/frankencoin__ethereum/contracts__Equity.sol", "workspace/sources/frankencoin__ethereum/contracts__Frankencoin.sol", "workspace/sources/frankencoin__ethereum/contracts__interface__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/frankencoin__ethereum/contracts__interface__IERC677Receiver.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "infinifi", "protocol_name": "infiniFi", "rank": 163, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x7a5c5dba4fbd0e1e1a2ecdbe752fae55f6e842b3", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/infinifi__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/infinifi__ethereum.json", "raw_state/infinifi__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/infinifi__ethereum/lib__solmate__src__utils__FixedPointMathLib.sol", "workspace/sources/infinifi__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__structs__EnumerableSet.sol", "workspace/sources/infinifi__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Pausable.sol", "workspace/sources/infinifi__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Arrays.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "curve-llamalend", "protocol_name": "Curve LlamaLend", "rank": 164, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0xcaec110c784c9df37240a8ce096d352a75922dea", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/curve-llamalend__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/curve-llamalend__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/curve-llamalend__arbitrum.json" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "curve-llamalend", "protocol_name": "Curve LlamaLend", "rank": 164, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xea6876dde9e3467564acbee1ed5bac88783205e0", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/curve-llamalend__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/curve-llamalend__ethereum.json", "raw_state/curve-llamalend__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/curve-llamalend__ethereum/OneWayLendingFactory.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "curve-llamalend", "protocol_name": "Curve LlamaLend", "rank": 164, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0x5ea8f3d674c70b020586933a0a5b250734798bef", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/curve-llamalend__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/curve-llamalend__optimism.json", "raw_state/curve-llamalend__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/curve-llamalend__optimism/OneWayLendingFactory.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "bitwise-uscc", "protocol_name": "Bitwise USCC", "rank": 165, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x14d60e7fdc0d71d8611742720e4c50e7a974020c", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/bitwise-uscc__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "ProxyAdmin upgrade path", "upgrade_guard": "ProxyAdmin ownership", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner()", "authority_contract_or_state": "ProxyAdmin owner", "terminal_actor": "0x8abC89D9b56dFD90dA18e8E18CFaC9111100bDd1", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/bitwise-uscc__ethereum.json", "raw_state/bitwise-uscc__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/bitwise-uscc__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/bitwise-uscc__ethereum__impl/protocol__token__src__fund__v1.3.0__FundTokenV1_3_0.sol", "workspace/sources/bitwise-uscc__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__ERC1967__ERC1967Proxy.sol", "workspace/sources/bitwise-uscc__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__Proxy.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> ProxyAdmin.owner(). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0x8abC89D9b56dFD90dA18e8E18CFaC9111100bDd1, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "crvusd", "protocol_name": "crvUSD", "rank": 166, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xc9332fdcb1c491dcc683bae86fe3cb70360738bc", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/crvusd__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/crvusd__ethereum.json", "raw_state/crvusd__ethereum.json" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "treehouse-protocol", "protocol_name": "Treehouse Protocol", "rank": 168, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x551d155760ae96050439ad24ae98a96c765d761b", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/treehouse-protocol__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/treehouse-protocol__ethereum.json", "raw_state/treehouse-protocol__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/treehouse-protocol__ethereum/contracts__interfaces__IWETH9.sol", "workspace/sources/treehouse-protocol__ethereum/contracts__InternalAccountingUnit.sol", "workspace/sources/treehouse-protocol__ethereum/contracts__libs__BlacklistableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/treehouse-protocol__ethereum/contracts__libs__Rescuable.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "Application implementation source contains UUPS machinery, but the measured live target has no active proxy DELEGATECALL path and standard implementation/admin slots are zero; treated as a direct/non-upgradeable live deployment.", "notes": "Application implementation source contains UUPS machinery, but the measured live target has no active proxy DELEGATECALL path and standard implementation/admin slots are zero; treated as a direct/non-upgradeable live deployment.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "swell-l2-farm", "protocol_name": "Swell L2 Farm", "rank": 169, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x38d43a6cb8da0e855a42fb6b0733a0498531d774", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/swell-l2-farm__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/swell-l2-farm__ethereum.json", "raw_state/swell-l2-farm__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/swell-l2-farm__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/swell-l2-farm__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/swell-l2-farm__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__ReentrancyGuard.sol", "workspace/sources/swell-l2-farm__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__Ownable2Step.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "stake.link-liquid", "protocol_name": "stake.link liquid", "rank": 170, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xb8b295df2cd735b15be5eb419517aa626fc43cd5", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/stake.link-liquid__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner() -> timelock", "terminal_actor": "0xb72d8F5213b3E52FAf13Aa074b03C4788e78349F", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 86400, "governance_requirement": "enforced 86400-second timelock", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/stake.link-liquid__ethereum.json", "raw_state/stake.link-liquid__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/stake.link-liquid__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/stake.link-liquid__ethereum__impl/contracts__core__base__StakingRewardsPool.sol", "workspace/sources/stake.link-liquid__ethereum__impl/contracts__core__interfaces__IERC677Receiver.sol", "workspace/sources/stake.link-liquid__ethereum__impl/contracts__core__interfaces__IStrategy.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner and must traverse an enforced delay of 86400 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund", "protocol_name": "Apollo Diversified Credit Securitize Fund", "rank": 173, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x17418038ecf73ba4026c4f428547bf099706f27b", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade", "upgrade_guard": "onlyMaster (owner OR trust-service ROLE_MASTER)", "authorization_dependency": "onlyMaster authorization with owner OR master-role branch", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner()/ROLE_MASTER authorization", "terminal_actor": "0x59c1eAcEc450c57Dcb9b8725d0F96635C2b676Ee", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none; owner branch independently permits immediate authorization", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__ethereum.json", "raw_state/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__ethereum__impl/contracts__utils__BaseDSContract.sol", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__ethereum__impl/contracts__compliance__ComplianceConfigurationService.sol", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__ethereum__impl/contracts__compliance__ComplianceService.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on onlyMaster authorization with owner OR master-role branch. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0x59c1eAcEc450c57Dcb9b8725d0F96635C2b676Ee, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund", "protocol_name": "Apollo Diversified Credit Securitize Fund", "rank": 173, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0xfce60bbc52a5705cec5b445501fbaf3274dc43d0", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade", "upgrade_guard": "onlyMaster (owner OR trust-service ROLE_MASTER)", "authorization_dependency": "onlyMaster authorization with owner OR master-role branch", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner()/ROLE_MASTER authorization", "terminal_actor": "0x59c1eAcEc450c57Dcb9b8725d0F96635C2b676Ee", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none; owner branch independently permits immediate authorization", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__polygon.json", "raw_state/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__polygon__impl/contracts__utils__BaseDSContract.sol", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__polygon__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__polygon__impl/contracts__compliance__ComplianceConfigurationService.sol", "workspace/sources/apollo-diversified-credit-securitize-fund__polygon__impl/contracts__compliance__ComplianceService.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on onlyMaster authorization with owner OR master-role branch. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0x59c1eAcEc450c57Dcb9b8725d0F96635C2b676Ee, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "arrakis-modular", "protocol_name": "Arrakis Modular", "rank": 175, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0x820fb8127a689327c863de8433278d6181123982", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/arrakis-modular__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/arrakis-modular__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/arrakis-modular__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__arbitrum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__governance__TimelockController.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__arbitrum/src__TimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__arbitrum/src__interfaces__ITimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__arbitrum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__structs__EnumerableSet.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "arrakis-modular", "protocol_name": "Arrakis Modular", "rank": 175, "chain": "base", "address": "0x820fb8127a689327c863de8433278d6181123982", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/arrakis-modular__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/arrakis-modular__base.json", "raw_state/arrakis-modular__base.json", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__governance__TimelockController.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__base/src__TimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__base/src__interfaces__ITimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__structs__EnumerableSet.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "arrakis-modular", "protocol_name": "Arrakis Modular", "rank": 175, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x820fb8127a689327c863de8433278d6181123982", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/arrakis-modular__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/arrakis-modular__bsc.json", "raw_state/arrakis-modular__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__governance__TimelockController.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__bsc/src__TimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__bsc/src__interfaces__ITimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__structs__EnumerableSet.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "arrakis-modular", "protocol_name": "Arrakis Modular", "rank": 175, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x820fb8127a689327c863de8433278d6181123982", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/arrakis-modular__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/arrakis-modular__ethereum.json", "raw_state/arrakis-modular__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__governance__TimelockController.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__ethereum/src__TimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__ethereum/src__interfaces__ITimeLock.sol", "workspace/sources/arrakis-modular__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__structs__EnumerableSet.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "solvbtc-lsts", "protocol_name": "SolvBTC LSTs", "rank": 176, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xeb28877d7e3dba5bcd4d0a1474c31f8afb2d6052", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/solvbtc-lsts__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "transparent EIP-1967 proxy", "upgrade_sink": "proxy upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "admin/controller", "authorization_dependency": "EIP-1967 admin -> timelock/controller", "authority_contract_or_state": "timelock controller with zero minimum delay", "terminal_actor": "0xFeeB1ff19b37BBe8F1E2A61FbCF49541763F96A4", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock/controller", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "controller is timelock-shaped but getMinDelay() is 0 at the pinned block; no enforced nonzero delay", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/solvbtc-lsts__ethereum.json", "raw_state/solvbtc-lsts__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/solvbtc-lsts__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__transparent__TransparentUpgradeableProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/solvbtc-lsts__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__token__ERC20__ERC20Upgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/solvbtc-lsts__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20Upgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/solvbtc-lsts__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20Upgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is transparent EIP-1967 proxy; the upgrade path depends on EIP-1967 admin -> timelock/controller. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is timelock/controller 0xFeeB1ff19b37BBe8F1E2A61FbCF49541763F96A4, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zerobase-cedefi", "protocol_name": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi", "rank": 178, "chain": "arbitrum", "address": "0xcc5df5c68d8c991035b6a437d4e00a99875228e4", "pinned_block": 503321313, "workspace_record": "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__arbitrum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__arbitrum.json", "raw_state/zerobase-cedefi__arbitrum.json", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__arbitrum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__arbitrum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__arbitrum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Pausable.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__arbitrum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__AccessControl.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zerobase-cedefi", "protocol_name": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi", "rank": 178, "chain": "base", "address": "0xcc5df5c68d8c991035b6a437d4e00a99875228e4", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__base.json", "raw_state/zerobase-cedefi__base.json", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Pausable.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__base/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__AccessControl.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zerobase-cedefi", "protocol_name": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi", "rank": 178, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0xcc5df5c68d8c991035b6a437d4e00a99875228e4", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__bsc.json", "raw_state/zerobase-cedefi__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__bsc__impl/src__utils.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__bsc/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Pausable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zerobase-cedefi", "protocol_name": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi", "rank": 178, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x9ef52d8953d184840f2c69096b7b3a7da7093685", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__ethereum.json", "raw_state/zerobase-cedefi__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Pausable.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__AccessControl.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zerobase-cedefi", "protocol_name": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi", "rank": 178, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0xcc5df5c68d8c991035b6a437d4e00a99875228e4", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__optimism.json", "raw_state/zerobase-cedefi__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__optimism/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__optimism/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__optimism/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Pausable.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__optimism/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__AccessControl.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zerobase-cedefi", "protocol_name": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi", "rank": 178, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0xcc5df5c68d8c991035b6a437d4e00a99875228e4", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zerobase-cedefi__polygon.json", "raw_state/zerobase-cedefi__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__polygon/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__IERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__polygon/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__token__ERC20__utils__SafeERC20.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__polygon/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__Pausable.sol", "workspace/sources/zerobase-cedefi__polygon/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__access__AccessControl.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "circle-gateway", "protocol_name": "Circle Gateway", "rank": 181, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x77777777dcc4d5a8b6e418fd04d8997ef11000ee", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/circle-gateway__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner()", "terminal_actor": "0x2A6A86466F181721ec8ff946967b56f1AA4758c5", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/circle-gateway__ethereum.json", "raw_state/circle-gateway__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/circle-gateway__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/circle-gateway__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__Ownable2StepUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/circle-gateway__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__proxy__utils__Initializable.sol", "workspace/sources/circle-gateway__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__utils__cryptography__ECDSA.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0x2A6A86466F181721ec8ff946967b56f1AA4758c5, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "usdcx", "protocol_name": "USDCx", "rank": 182, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x8888888199b2df864bf678259607d6d5ebb4e3ce", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/usdcx__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "upgradeToAndCall / UUPS path", "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": "upgrade authorization guard not established from available verified source", "authority_contract_or_state": "unknown authorization dependency", "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": "unresolved", "upgrade_delay": null, "governance_requirement": "unknown", "upgrade_path_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "UNRESOLVED", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/usdcx__ethereum.json", "raw_state/usdcx__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/usdcx__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__ERC1967__ERC1967Proxy.sol", "workspace/sources/usdcx__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__ERC1967__ERC1967Utils.sol", "workspace/sources/usdcx__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__Proxy.sol", "workspace/sources/usdcx__ethereum/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__beacon__IBeacon.sol" ], "confidence": "LOW", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism is identifiable as UUPS / ERC1967, but the authorization path cannot be walked to a sufficiently established terminal controller from the blinded evidence; the upgrade-path outcome is UNRESOLVED. The live deployment exposes UUPS/ERC1967 upgrade behavior and owner(), but the neutral source bundle does not establish that owner() is the actual _authorizeUpgrade predicate; no tier is inferred from owner() alone.", "notes": "The live deployment exposes UUPS/ERC1967 upgrade behavior and owner(), but the neutral source bundle does not establish that owner() is the actual _authorizeUpgrade predicate; no tier is inferred from owner() alone.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zama", "protocol_name": "Zama", "rank": 184, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xeb5015ff021db115ace010f23f55c2591059bba0", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/zama__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner followed by DAO permission control", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner -> owner is DAO/proxy with permissioned upgrade control", "authority_contract_or_state": "DAO upgrade permission (UPGRADE_DAO_PERMISSION_ID)", "terminal_actor": "DAO permission holder set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "permission-gated DAO upgrade control; effective permission holder set not publicly established in the neutral evidence", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zama__ethereum.json", "raw_state/zama__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/zama__ethereum__impl/contracts__ConfidentialTokenWrappersRegistry.sol", "workspace/sources/zama__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__interfaces__draft-IERC1822.sol", "workspace/sources/zama__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__interfaces__IERC1967.sol", "workspace/sources/zama__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__beacon__IBeacon.sol" ], "confidence": "MEDIUM", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (_authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner -> owner is DAO/proxy with permissioned upgrade control) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The authority contract and upgrade permission are identifiable, but effective permission holders are not enumerated; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE.", "notes": "The authority contract and upgrade permission are identifiable, but effective permission holders are not enumerated; classified AUTHORITY_OPAQUE.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "tori-finance", "protocol_name": "Tori Finance", "rank": 185, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xd0580192e98ea6ceb9c7b6191ed2e27560911697", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/tori-finance__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyRole(TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authority_contract_or_state": "TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE -> ToriTimelock", "terminal_actor": "0x7af35ab3E5373dA511c5F1331f44335a36dA1A55", "terminal_actor_type": "timelock", "upgrade_delay": 86400, "governance_requirement": "enforced 86400-second timelock", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/tori-finance__ethereum.json", "raw_state/tori-finance__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/tori-finance__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__access__extensions__IAccessControlDefaultAdminRules.sol", "workspace/sources/tori-finance__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__access__IAccessControl.sol", "workspace/sources/tori-finance__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__access__AccessControlUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/tori-finance__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts-upgradeable__access__extensions__AccessControlDefaultAdminRulesUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE) and must traverse an enforced delay of 86400 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "moonwell-lending", "protocol_name": "Moonwell Lending", "rank": 186, "chain": "base", "address": "0xfbb21d0380bee3312b33c4353c8936a0f13ef26c", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/moonwell-lending__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "Unitroller / Comptroller delegator", "upgrade_sink": "Unitroller implementation/admin upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "admin = TemporalGovernor", "authorization_dependency": "Unitroller admin", "authority_contract_or_state": "TemporalGovernor governance chain", "terminal_actor": "0x8b621804a7637b781e2BbD58e256a591F2dF7d51", "terminal_actor_type": "governor/executor", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "TemporalGovernor governance consent required", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/moonwell-lending__base.json", "raw_state/moonwell-lending__base.json", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__base__impl/src__core__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__base/src__core__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__base__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__security__ReentrancyGuard.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__base__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__utils__Initializable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is Unitroller / Comptroller delegator; the path depends on Unitroller admin and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "moonwell-lending", "protocol_name": "Moonwell Lending", "rank": 186, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xdec80bb934397575594e91970b37baf65f5b21be", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/moonwell-lending__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "Unitroller / Comptroller delegator", "upgrade_sink": "Unitroller implementation/admin upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "admin = governor proxy", "authorization_dependency": "Unitroller admin", "authority_contract_or_state": "governor-controlled admin", "terminal_actor": "0x8769B70ac7c93AF0e75de0D69877709B66d75838", "terminal_actor_type": "governor", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "governor proposal/vote required before execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/moonwell-lending__ethereum.json", "raw_state/moonwell-lending__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__ethereum__impl/src__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__ethereum/src__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__security__ReentrancyGuard.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__utils__Initializable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is Unitroller / Comptroller delegator; the path depends on Unitroller admin and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "moonwell-lending", "protocol_name": "Moonwell Lending", "rank": 186, "chain": "optimism", "address": "0xca889f40aae37fff165bccf69aef1e82b5c511b9", "pinned_block": 156673546, "workspace_record": "workspace/moonwell-lending__optimism.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "Unitroller / Comptroller delegator", "upgrade_sink": "Unitroller implementation/admin upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "admin = TemporalGovernor", "authorization_dependency": "Unitroller admin", "authority_contract_or_state": "TemporalGovernor governance chain", "terminal_actor": "0x17C9ba3fDa7EC71CcfD75f978Ef31E21927aFF3d", "terminal_actor_type": "governor/executor", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "TemporalGovernor governance consent required", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/moonwell-lending__optimism.json", "raw_state/moonwell-lending__optimism.json", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__optimism__impl/src__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__optimism/src__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__optimism__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__security__ReentrancyGuard.sol", "workspace/sources/moonwell-lending__optimism__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts__contracts__proxy__utils__Initializable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is Unitroller / Comptroller delegator; the path depends on Unitroller admin and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "blast-bridge", "protocol_name": "Blast Bridge", "rank": 187, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x5f6ae08b8aeb7078cf2f96afb089d7c9f51da47d", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/blast-bridge__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyOwner", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner()", "terminal_actor": "0x67CA7Ca75b69711cfd48B44eC3F64E469BaF608C", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/blast-bridge__ethereum.json", "raw_state/blast-bridge__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/blast-bridge__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/blast-bridge__ethereum__impl/src__LaunchBridge_v3.sol", "workspace/sources/blast-bridge__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__Ownable2StepUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/blast-bridge__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__security__PausableUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyOwner. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x67CA7Ca75b69711cfd48B44eC3F64E469BaF608C, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "pulsechain-bridge", "protocol_name": "PulseChain Bridge", "rank": 189, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x1715a3e4a142d8b698131108995174f37aeba10d", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/pulsechain-bridge__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "EternalStorageProxy / custom upgradeability proxy", "upgrade_sink": "upgradeTo / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyUpgradeabilityOwner", "authorization_dependency": "upgradeTo/upgradeToAndCall onlyUpgradeabilityOwner", "authority_contract_or_state": "upgradeabilityOwner", "terminal_actor": "0x13A9594a2696D3c35F9D6E4Be6b332f699C57801", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "none", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/pulsechain-bridge__ethereum.json", "raw_state/pulsechain-bridge__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/pulsechain-bridge__ethereum/EternalStorageProxy.sol", "workspace/sources/pulsechain-bridge__ethereum__impl/ForeignOmnibridge.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is EternalStorageProxy / custom upgradeability proxy; the upgrade path depends on upgradeTo/upgradeToAndCall onlyUpgradeabilityOwner. The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is EOA 0x13A9594a2696D3c35F9D6E4Be6b332f699C57801, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "matrixdock-xaum", "protocol_name": "MatrixDock XAUM", "rank": 190, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0x23ae4fd8e7844cdbc97775496ebd0e8248656028", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/matrixdock-xaum__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "delayed UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "scheduled UUPS upgrade execution", "upgrade_guard": "owner authorization plus delay", "authorization_dependency": "owner-authorized upgrade with scheduled delay state", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner + enforced upgrade delay", "terminal_actor": "0xb573c94260582f0715FC477928B04A2708dd36D7", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 14400, "governance_requirement": "enforced 14400-second upgrade delay", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/matrixdock-xaum__bsc.json", "raw_state/matrixdock-xaum__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__bsc__impl/contracts__DelayedUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__bsc__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__bsc__impl/contracts__interfaces__ICCClient.sol", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__bsc__impl/contracts__MToken.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is delayed UUPS / ERC1967; the path depends on owner-authorized upgrade with scheduled delay state and must traverse an enforced delay of 14400 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "matrixdock-xaum", "protocol_name": "MatrixDock XAUM", "rank": 190, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x2103e845c5e135493bb6c2a4f0b8651956ea8682", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/matrixdock-xaum__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "delayed UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "scheduled UUPS upgrade execution", "upgrade_guard": "owner authorization plus delay", "authorization_dependency": "owner-authorized upgrade with scheduled delay state", "authority_contract_or_state": "owner + enforced upgrade delay", "terminal_actor": "0xb573c94260582f0715FC477928B04A2708dd36D7", "terminal_actor_type": "EOA", "upgrade_delay": 14400, "governance_requirement": "enforced 14400-second upgrade delay", "upgrade_path_tier": "T2", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T2", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/matrixdock-xaum__ethereum.json", "raw_state/matrixdock-xaum__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__ethereum__impl/contracts__DelayedUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__ethereum__impl/@openzeppelin__contracts__proxy__utils__UUPSUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__ethereum__impl/@chainlink__contracts__src__v0.8__shared__interfaces__AggregatorV3Interface.sol", "workspace/sources/matrixdock-xaum__ethereum__impl/contracts__interfaces__ICCClient.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is delayed UUPS / ERC1967; the path depends on owner-authorized upgrade with scheduled delay state and must traverse an enforced delay of 14400 seconds before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T2.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "unitas-usdu", "protocol_name": "Unitas USDu", "rank": 191, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0xea953ea6634d55dac6697c436b1e81a679db5882", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/unitas-usdu__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/unitas-usdu__bsc.json", "raw_state/unitas-usdu__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/unitas-usdu__bsc/contracts__interfaces__IUSDuDefinitions.sol", "workspace/sources/unitas-usdu__bsc/contracts__USDu.sol", "workspace/sources/unitas-usdu__bsc/@openzeppelin__contracts__access__Ownable.sol", "workspace/sources/unitas-usdu__bsc/@openzeppelin__contracts__access__Ownable2Step.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "puffer-stake", "protocol_name": "Puffer Stake", "rank": 192, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xd9a442856c234a39a81a089c06451ebaa4306a72", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/puffer-stake__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "restricted / AccessManager canCall", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade restricted", "authority_contract_or_state": "AccessManager authority.canCall permission", "terminal_actor": "AccessManager role/selector holder set", "terminal_actor_type": "opaque authority set", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "AccessManager permission required; effective holders for upgrade selector not established", "upgrade_path_tier": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "AUTHORITY_OPAQUE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/puffer-stake__ethereum.json", "raw_state/puffer-stake__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/puffer-stake__ethereum__impl/node_modules__@openzeppelin__contracts__access__manager__IAccessManager.sol", "workspace/sources/puffer-stake__ethereum__impl/src__PufferVaultV5.sol", "workspace/sources/puffer-stake__ethereum__impl/src__PufferVaultStorage.sol", "workspace/sources/puffer-stake__ethereum__impl/src__interface__Lido__IStETH.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "The upgrade mechanism and authorization dependency (_authorizeUpgrade restricted) are identifiable, but the effective holder/controller set cannot be established from the public blinded evidence, so the outcome is AUTHORITY_OPAQUE rather than an inferred T1/T2/T3. The AccessManager dependency is directly identified, but the effective holder set for the upgrade selector is not established from public evidence.", "notes": "The AccessManager dependency is directly identified, but the effective holder set for the upgrade selector is not established from public evidence.", "second_reviewed": true, "second_review_decision": "AGREE", "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary, confirmed by human second review (AGREE)" }, { "protocol_slug": "flux-finance", "protocol_name": "Flux Finance", "rank": 193, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x95af143a021df745bc78e845b54591c53a8b3a51", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/flux-finance__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "Unitroller / Comptroller delegator", "upgrade_sink": "Unitroller implementation/admin upgrade operation", "upgrade_guard": "admin = Timelock", "authorization_dependency": "Unitroller admin", "authority_contract_or_state": "Timelock -> GovernorBravo governance chain", "terminal_actor": "0x336505EC1BcC1A020EeDe459f57581725D23465A", "terminal_actor_type": "governor", "upgrade_delay": 86400, "governance_requirement": "GovernorBravo proposal/vote required before 86400-second timelock execution", "upgrade_path_tier": "T3", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T3", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/flux-finance__ethereum.json", "raw_state/flux-finance__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/flux-finance__ethereum__impl/contracts__lending__compound__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/flux-finance__ethereum/contracts__lending__compound__Unitroller.sol", "workspace/sources/flux-finance__ethereum__impl/contracts__lending__compound__Comptroller.sol", "workspace/sources/flux-finance__ethereum__impl/contracts__lending__compound__ComptrollerInterface.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is Unitroller / Comptroller delegator; the path depends on Unitroller admin and reaches a governance voting/consent system before execution, so the upgrade-path tier is T3.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "zircuit-staking", "protocol_name": "Zircuit Staking", "rank": 194, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0xf047ab4c75cebf0eb9ed34ae2c186f3611aeafa6", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/zircuit-staking__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/zircuit-staking__ethereum.json", "raw_state/zircuit-staking__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/zircuit-staking__ethereum/contracts__interface__IMigrator.sol", "workspace/sources/zircuit-staking__ethereum/contracts__interface__IWETH.sol", "workspace/sources/zircuit-staking__ethereum/contracts__interface__IZtakingPool.sol", "workspace/sources/zircuit-staking__ethereum/contracts__ZtakingPool.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "frax", "protocol_name": "Frax", "rank": 195, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x853d955acef822db058eb8505911ed77f175b99e", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/frax__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/frax__ethereum.json", "raw_state/frax__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/frax__ethereum/Timelock.sol", "workspace/sources/frax__ethereum/AccessControl.sol", "workspace/sources/frax__ethereum/Address.sol", "workspace/sources/frax__ethereum/AggregatorV3Interface.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "brickken", "protocol_name": "Brickken", "rank": 196, "chain": "base", "address": "0x278d7bdc2451b0fa4087a68ce084a86cb91d4d83", "pinned_block": 51078261, "workspace_record": "workspace/brickken__base.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authority_contract_or_state": "DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member", "terminal_actor": "0xf47AB48D82E3c202838875275BdA93dd97F82970", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/brickken__base.json", "raw_state/brickken__base.json", "workspace/sources/brickken__base__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__base__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__base__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__base__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xf47AB48D82E3c202838875275BdA93dd97F82970, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "brickken", "protocol_name": "Brickken", "rank": 196, "chain": "bsc", "address": "0xce4529fe88df480bd777d3e32dfd7032e6c685ff", "pinned_block": 120853740, "workspace_record": "workspace/brickken__bsc.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authority_contract_or_state": "DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member", "terminal_actor": "0x5eBAbA98d0C6f617ABD6351f3c56CDD1E9b2ab04", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/brickken__bsc.json", "raw_state/brickken__bsc.json", "workspace/sources/brickken__bsc__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__bsc__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__bsc__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__bsc__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x5eBAbA98d0C6f617ABD6351f3c56CDD1E9b2ab04, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "brickken", "protocol_name": "Brickken", "rank": 196, "chain": "ethereum", "address": "0x91af681c85ca98efc5d69c1b62e6f435030969db", "pinned_block": 25938899, "workspace_record": "workspace/brickken__ethereum.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authority_contract_or_state": "DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member", "terminal_actor": "0xFa7578cE42858D0B93fcD490D59231c0c05C84de", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 4", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/brickken__ethereum.json", "raw_state/brickken__ethereum.json", "workspace/sources/brickken__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__ethereum__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0xFa7578cE42858D0B93fcD490D59231c0c05C84de, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "brickken", "protocol_name": "Brickken", "rank": 196, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0x1bb57e2abf2822c01ccaebccbc9d16c7fd0c1956", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/brickken__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "UUPS / ERC1967", "upgrade_sink": "_authorizeUpgrade / upgradeToAndCall", "upgrade_guard": "onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authorization_dependency": "_authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE)", "authority_contract_or_state": "DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member", "terminal_actor": "0x23F4c83b0eac014Ec59D4549FF11bd144ACAdEa5", "terminal_actor_type": "Safe multisig", "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "no enforced delay; Safe threshold 3", "upgrade_path_tier": "T1", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "T1", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned on-chain state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/brickken__polygon.json", "raw_state/brickken__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/brickken__polygon__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__polygon__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlEnumerableUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__polygon__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__AccessControlUpgradeable.sol", "workspace/sources/brickken__polygon__impl/lib__openzeppelin-contracts-upgradeable__contracts__access__IAccessControlUpgradeable.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "Upgrade mechanism is UUPS / ERC1967; the upgrade path depends on _authorizeUpgrade onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE). The terminal control evidenced at the pinned block is Safe multisig 0x23F4c83b0eac014Ec59D4549FF11bd144ACAdEa5, with no enforced nonzero delay or governance vote on this upgrade path, so the upgrade-path tier is T1.", "notes": null, "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" }, { "protocol_slug": "tangible-rwa", "protocol_name": "Tangible RWA", "rank": 197, "chain": "polygon", "address": "0xb0e54b88bb0043a938563fe8a77f4dde2eb0cfc0", "pinned_block": 93493892, "workspace_record": "workspace/tangible-rwa__polygon.json", "upgradeable_status": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "upgrade_mechanism": "none at live deployment", "upgrade_sink": null, "upgrade_guard": null, "authorization_dependency": null, "authority_contract_or_state": null, "terminal_actor": null, "terminal_actor_type": null, "upgrade_delay": 0, "governance_requirement": "not applicable", "upgrade_path_tier": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNRESOLVED in this blinded AI pass; upgrade path adjudicated separately", "overall_fund_reaching_tier": "UNRESOLVED", "upgrade_is_fastest_fund_reaching_path": "UNKNOWN", "authority_outcome": "NON_UPGRADEABLE", "evidence_basis": "verified source + pinned runtime/state", "evidence_refs": [ "workspace/tangible-rwa__polygon.json", "raw_state/tangible-rwa__polygon.json", "workspace/sources/tangible-rwa__polygon/contracts__Factory.sol", "workspace/sources/tangible-rwa__polygon/contracts__abstract__AdminAndTangibleAccess.sol", "workspace/sources/tangible-rwa__polygon/contracts__interfaces__IFactory.sol", "workspace/sources/tangible-rwa__polygon/contracts__interfaces__ITangiblePriceManager.sol" ], "confidence": "HIGH", "reasoning_summary": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "notes": "No live implementation-change path was established at the pinned deployment from verified source/runtime state.", "second_reviewed": false, "second_review_decision": null, "final_label_source": "AI-blinded primary (not in second-review subset)" } ] }